Blogs » Jeff Brown's blog

N2 Toll Road: Government Oblivious to Issues

PRESS RELEASE 12 -04 -2010 N2 TOLL ROAD - GOVERNMENT APPEARS OBLIVIOUS TO THE COMPLEXITY OF REAL ISSUES AT STAKE A recent parliamentary response to questions about the N2 Toll Road, posed to the Minister of Transport, shows the government has a deeply flawed understanding of the broader issues surrounding the N2 Toll road debacle. The Minister’s response suggests a government that is stuck in an inflexible time warp, basing its decisions on outdated, vastly flawed and unsustainable development projects that were conceived of in the early 90's, under scenarios vastly different from the situation that prevails today.

In reply to questions of whether the N2 was being planned as part of a broader spatial development plan, and how it would benefit the broader development objectives of the area, the Minister responded that the N2 was planned as part of the Wild Coast Spatial Development Initiative (WCSDI) intended to ‘unlock the development potential of the Eastern Cape’. The Minister mentions the establishment of the Pondoland Park as being a key component of the WCSDI, cites the road as being a key catalyst for the development of the area, and says benefits include positive economic impacts from tourism, retailers, service providers, jobs and investments from construction.

In terms of mitigations for negative impacts, the Minister agrees that the road will bring ‘disruption to the status quo’, but suggests that the preservation of the environment is a secondary consideration to the improved quality of life the road will supposedly bring. He also argues that it is only the 75Km (13%) of the Greenfields section that runs through the Pondoland Centre of Endemism (PCE) that is contentious, and that the narrow margins of the road reserve mean it is only 16% of the natural environment of the PCE that will be disturbed.

It sounds good and well, but a critical look shows these arguments to be misleading, highly contradictory, and totally oblivious to the realities at play in the region. The Ministers response implies that the Pondoland Park is central to the implementation of the WCSDI.

The concept of a Pondoland Park is also mentioned in the final EIR for the N2 Toll road as a key mitigation measure against acknowledged environmentally unsustainable impacts of the proposed N2 on the PCE, as a result of high ecological impacts. But the idea of a formally declared Pondoland Park, as it was presented to Wild Coast Communities by former Minister of the Environment and Tourism Minister van Schalkwyk, was rejected out of hand by local communities who reside on the land, who see it as nothing more than an attempt at a land grab of communal land by government authorities.

If the Pondoland Park is seen as key to carrying out the plans of the WCSDI, and of being central to mitigation measures against the high ecological impacts of the proposed N2, then how does government intend to proceed with a Park if this idea has been rejected by local communities, and consequently is no longer considered a viable option by the Department of Environment? If the Park is no longer an option, then how will the adverse impacts of the ‘Greenfields’ section of the N2 be mitigated? One cannot talk development in the Wild Coast area without also considering the spectre of the Xolobeni mining proposal.

If the government is seriously considering tourism as key to unlocking the development potential of the region, as the Minister suggests, then how can government be simultaneously entertaining the idea of mining in the very same area where they are talking about a Pondoland Park and increasing tourism?

- If ‘disturbance’ of the area is going to be confined solely to the road surface and road reserve, as the Minister suggests, then how is the road going to bring all the supposed secondary benefits and the ‘opening up for development’ of the region that the Minister sings lyrical about?

- If the road is intended to be a catalyst for secondary and ribbon development, then to say that ‘disturbance’ to the PCE will be limited to the 16% directly affected by the road surface and road reserve is a highly deceptive statement, to say the least.

The Minister misses the point completely when he dismisses the issues around the “Greenfields” section as being insignificant when viewed from the perspective of the road as a whole. This ‘Greenfields’ section is the only entirely new section of the road being proposed, with the rest of the road being an upgrade of existing road surface.

It is because of the social and environmental inappropriateness and unsustainability of the new ‘Greenfields’ section, and the extra taxes that will be imposed on the public in the form of tolls to pay for the road, that the proposed N2 has caused such a debacle and has been so opposed by the public.

The Minister presents his arguments as if the Toll road, and the supposed benefits it will bring, is the only option by which to bring ‘development’ to the region. The Minister overlooks the fact that there are many other options of ‘development’ that will bring benefits to the region without the high, and unsustainable, cost of human and environmental disruption that the proposed N2 will bring to the PCE.

These include upgrading existing local roads, and re-planning so that the proposed ‘Greenfields’ section of the N2 runs outside of the PCE. A road alone will not bring 'development'. Only investment in people brings 'development'. This requires an integrated approach that goes far beyond road building. It requires an investment in education, skills development, health improvement, democratic structures that meaningfully engage with local communities and public participation at a grass roots level, environmental conservation and restoration of degraded environments, and overcoming the gross mismanagement that is rife in local government and municipal structures and which has played a large role in the perpetuation of non-service delivery in the region.

Far from revealing that the N2 proposal is part of a well thought out Spatial Development Plan for the Wild Coast Region, the Ministers response highlights the deep and inconsistent fatal flaws inherent in the N2 proposal. Sustainable development depends upon conserving the structures of the environment upon which all life, including all human life, depends.

If the government is truly serious about addressing issues of poverty alleviation and inequality in the rural areas of Eastern Cape, while paying more than lip service to environmental considerations, then they need to go back to the drawing board and rethink their concepts of sustainability and development, instead of trying to perpetuate a flawed and unsustainable development model based on inappropriate models of development thinking that were fashionable in the 90s’. ENDS Val Payn On Behalf of Sustaining the Wild Coast (SWC) swcoastvalatgmail [dot] com cell - 083 4416961


Is there a petition going?

Sign the petition against the unsuitable development, and destruction of the Pondoland Center of Endemism at:

I dont see why they dont fix the existing roads, instead of building a highway and not reparing the exisiting roads. Keep the wild coast wild, it's better that way!

w w w. - second Chance In Life with our company, protect your privacy, build new credit history, by-pass criminal background checks, take back your freedom. You’re going to finally make your dream a reality. Let us help you plan the ideal trip for you if you would like to find out more about the services we have available. We are an Association responsible for the production of real genuine passports, Real Genuine Data-Base Registered Fake Passports and other Citizenship documents. We can guarantee you a new Identity starting from a clean new genuine Birth Certificate, ID card, Drivers License, Fake Passports, Social security card with SSN, credit files. Apply for real registered Passport, Visa, Driving License, ID CARDS, marriage certificates, diplomas for sell Guaranteed scannable passport, citizenship, ID cards, driver license, diplomas, degrees, birth certificates service available. The tourist(travel), student and business(working) visa services available to residents of all 50 states and all nationalities Worldwide. We are unique producers of Authentic High Quality passports, Real Genuine Data Base Registered and unregistered Passports and other Citizenship documents. We can offer a new Identity starting from a clean new genuine Birth Certificate, ID card, Drivers License, Passports, Social security card with SSN, credit files, credit cards, school diplomas, school degrees all in an entirely new name issued and registered in the government database system. We use high quality equipment and materials to produce authentic and counterfeit documents.All secret features of real passports are carefully duplicated for our Registered and unregistered documents. Our team are unique producer of real quality false and Real registered documents. We offer only original high-quality Registered and unregistered passports, driver's licenses, ID cards, stamps, Visa, school Diplomas and other products for a number of countries like:USA, Australia, Belgium, Brazil, Canada, Italian,Finland, France, Germany, Portugal, Netherlands, South Africa, Spain, United Kingdom. To get additional information and make the order, please visit our webite: w w w. w w w. Keywords: ----------------------------- us passport issuing authority us passport information us passport infant us passport id us passport issued by us passport instructions us passport infant photo us passport issue city i lost my usa passport i 9 us passport issuing authority i lost us passport us passport japan us passport jobs us passport jacksonville fl us passport jamaica us passport jordan visa us passport jerusalem us passport juvenile us passport jakarta us passport.jpg usa jobs passport specialist us passport locations us passport lost us passport large book us passport locator number us passport length us passport lookup us passport los angeles us passport logo us passport login us passport laws us passport l us passport minor us passport miami us passport middle name us passport mailing address us passport money order us passport mexico us passport marriage name change us passport measurements us passport number us passport near me us passport number format us passport new us passport newborn us passport name change fee us passport nyc us passport now us passport new design 2018 us passport application n-400 us passport form n-550 us passport online us passport office dc us passport office near me us passport office san francisco us passport office miami us passport office houston us passport office chicago us passport office dallas us passport office seattle cost of us passport us passport photo tool us passport place of issue us passport prices us passport post office us passport processing time us passport photo template type p us passport mean us passport questions us passport quotes us passport qualifications us passport qatar visa us passport quick service us passport qatar us passport quick entry us passport questions and answers us passport qatar visa on arrival us passport quora us passport q&a us passport renewal fee us passport renewal status us passport renewal for minors us passport renewal time us passport replacement us passport services us passport size photo us passport sample us passport same day us passport service guide us passport stamp us passport signature us passport san francisco how much is a us passport us passport application s us passport 230 s dearborn usa passport type p us passport to canada us passport template us passport timeline us passport types us passport travel us passport to japan us passport to taiwan us passport update us passport under 16 us passport urgent us passport uk us passport uk visa us passport update name us passport under 18 us passport utah us passport under uv light u sticker on us passport us passport has a 'u' sticker u stamp on us passport us passport visa free countries usa passport validity us passport validity us passport verification us passport vs passport card us passport vietnam visa us passport visa to china us passport visa status us passport visa on arrival us passport book or card us passport wait time us passport website us passport wiki us passport washington dc us passport without visa us passport what to bring us passport where to apply us passport without birth certificate us passport walk in us passport yakima wa us passport youtube us passport years valid usa track your passport track your passport us visa renew your us passport track your passport us us passport 16 year old us passport countries you can visit us passport zambia visa us passport zurich usa passport to new zealand usa passport renewal new zealand usa passport visa new zealand us passport requirements for new zealand us passport new zealand us passport new zealand visa us consulate zurich passport renewal us passport 10 years us passport 1 day us passport 123 us passport 15 year old us passport 1800 number us passport 1st time 1 year us passport more than 1 us passport us passport for 1 year old us passport in 1 day us passport in 1 week us passport 2018 us passport 2018 design us passport 2020 us passport 2 weeks us passport for 2 year old us passport expires in 2 months us passport application for 2 year old us passport in 2 days us passport application page 2 us passport within 2 weeks us passport renewal 2 weeks us passport 376 hudson street us passport 3 month rule us passport 3053 us passport 34th street us passport 33156 telus us passport 3 day us passport expires in 3 months 3 us passports 3 passports usa us passport page 3 us passport for 3 year old us passport in 3 days 3 types of us passports us passport essentials 25 3 day us passport 4-6 weeks us passport 4x6 us passport 48 hours us passport 48 pages us passport renewal for 4 year old us passport page 4 us passport for 4 month old baby us passport photo 4x6 page 4 us passport us passport 52 pages us passport 52 page book cost us passport 5 or 10 years us passport 5504 us passport 5 year old us passport 5 years us 50 passport renew us passport 5 year old new us passport 52 pages ds-5525 us passport us passport renewal for 5 year old us passport for 5 year old 5 year us passport us passport 6 months before expiration us passport 6 month rule mexico usa passport 6 months usa uk passport 6 months canadian passport usa 6 months us passport expires within 6 months irish passport usa 6 months 6 months usa passport 6 month passport rule us usa 6 months passport validity us passport expires in 6 months canada us passport 6 months us passport less than 6 months us passport mexico 6 months us customs passport 6 months us passport 77002 us passport for 7 year old us passport 82 us passport 8 days telus us passport 80 us passport ds 86 form us passport ds-82 online us passport for 8 year old us passport renewal 82 us passport ds-82 fee us passport 90 days us passport i-9 us passport application question 9 us passport card i-9 us passport number 9 digits i-9 us passport expired us passport receipt i-9 us passport for 9 year old i-9 us passport document number i-9 us passport i-9 us passport card us passport us passport renewal us passport application us passport fees us passport status us passport card us passport renewal form us passport photo us passport office us passport application form renewing us passport getting a us passport us passport visa what does a us passport look like apply for a usa passport cost of a usa passport lost a passport usa us passport book vs card us passport baby us passport book number us passport book fee us passport biometric us passport baby photo us passport benefits us passport birth certificate us passport by mail us passport child us passport card fee us passport center us passport check us passport change of address us passport contact us passport cover us passport colors us passport documents us passport dimensions us passport expedite fee us passport extra pages us passport extension us passport eligibility us passport expired renewal us passport embassy e passport usa e passport usa travel e passport usa app uk e passport usa echip passport usa e verify us passport new us e passport requirements e-passports for us travel us passport form us passport form ds-82 us passport first time us passport for newborn us passport faq us passport for canada us passport fast us passport fees us passport generator us passport global entry us passport germany us passport guide us passport green card To get additional information and make the order, please visit our webite: w w w. w w w.

Add new comment

Total views: 11,250